Skip to content

Brown Herring Soup

Brown herring soup from Erken's Stor kokebok (1914): herring stock cooked from herring and trimmings from herring patties, thickened with a brown butter roux, seasoned with sherry, cayenne, boiled roots and mushrooms.

Source: Henriette Schønberg Erken, Stor kokebok, 1914-utg. s. 117 (falt i det fri)

Be the first to rate

About the dish

The recipe appears in the fish chapter right after the white herring soup, and uses the same herring stock - preferably leftovers (bones, heads and tails) from herring patties. A thrifty "second-day" dish of the kind Erken was known for.

How to make it

  1. 1

    Cook the stock

    Clean and wash the herring well. Place the herring, bones, heads and tails in cold, salted water and cook the fish completely down. Strain the stock.

  2. 2

    Brown the roux

    Brown the butter in a pot, stir in the flour and gradually thin with the strained stock to a smooth soup.

  3. 3

    Simmer

    Let the soup simmer for half an hour. Skim as needed.

  4. 4

    Cook the roots

    Cut the roots finely and cook them tender - preferably in the stock.

  5. 5

    Finish

    Add the boiled, finely cut roots, cayenne pepper, sherry and mushrooms to the soup. Season with salt and serve hot.

Changes from the original

Measurements converted to modern units (deciliters, grams, liters). "Roots" specified as carrot and celeriac/parsley root. Cayenne and salt set as "to taste."

In stores now

Clean, minimally processed groceries matched to the ingredients — approximate prices.

Product data and prices via Kassalapp. Prices are updated daily and may vary.

Time machine – what changed?

Pick two editions and see what Henriette Schønberg Erken added, removed or changed between them.

Modernised → 1949 (proofread, p. 142)~85% of the text changedremovedadded
8 stk sild (samt sild, samt ben, hoder og haler etter sildekarbonader). 2,5 l vann. efter sildekarbonader 2½ l. vann salt (etter smak). 75 g smør. gr. smør 75 g hvetemel. 200 g gr. hvetemel gule og hvite røtter (gulrot, sellerirot, persillerot). 1 dl sherry. 1 ½ del. sherry ½ liten boks champignon (liten boks). cayennepepper (etter smak). Rens og vask silden godt. Legg sild, ben, hoder og haler i kaldt, saltet vann og kok fisken helt ut. Sil kraften.. Brun smøret i en gryte, rør inn champignons kajenne. Kraften utkokes som ovenfor forklart. Smøret brunes, irøres melet og spe spes med den silte kraften litt om litt til en jevn suppe.. La suppen småkoke i en halv kraft; småkoker ½ time. Skum av etter behov.. Skjær røttene fint og kok dem møre — gjerne i kraften.. Ha de De kokte, finskårne røttene, cayennepepper, røtter, kajenne, sherry og champignon champignons has i suppen. Smak til med salt og server varm. Røttene kan kokes møre i kraften.

Note on Modernised

Mål omregnet til moderne enheter (deciliter, gram, liter). «Røtter» presisert som gulrot og sellerirot/persillerot. Cayenne og salt satt som «etter smak».

Community interpretations

Be the first to share your own version.

See interpretations →

Frequently asked questions

What is used for the stock in brown herring soup?
The stock is cooked from 8 herring plus the bones, heads and tails left over from herring patties, in 2.5 liters of water with salt. Then the stock is strained.
How is the brown thickening made?
75 g butter is browned, 75 g wheat flour is stirred in, and it is thinned with the strained stock. The soup simmers for 1/2 hour.
What goes into the soup at the end?
Boiled, finely cut yellow and white roots, cayenne, 1 deciliter of sherry and a small can of mushrooms. The roots can be cooked tender in the stock itself.
How many portions and how long does the recipe take?
The recipe is intended for 6 portions and takes about 90 minutes in all. It is from Henriette Schonberg Erken's "Stor kokebok" (1914), p. 117.

Equipment for this dish

Advertisement

We may earn a commission if you buy through these links. It does not affect the price.

Related recipes

More dishes in the same category from the archive

Read also

Kommentarer

Ingen kommentarer ennå. Bli den første til å dele!